VC-1015

HairProduct dossier

Four women settle chemical hair relaxer cancer claims in Chicago

Reuters reported that four women settled confidential cancer claims involving chemical hair relaxers, with L'Oréal USA among defendants in a Chicago case grouped with more than 12,700.

By Daniel Okafor3 min read623 words

Counter notes

  1. Four women reached a confidential settlement after a Chicago trial began last week.
  2. Every defendant settled; the amounts remain undisclosed and no liability was admitted.
  3. Reuters reported more than 12,700 related cases consolidated before a Chicago judge.
  4. Arizona’s attorney general sued L’Oréal in September, alleging consumer fraud and downplayed health risks.
  5. The plaintiffs are MaryAnne Lindsey, Surenthia Jenkins, Miranda Lofton and Sandra Simpson.
Settlements Reached in Key Lawsuits About Chemical Hair Straighteners' Link to Cancer
PlateSettlements Reached in Key Lawsuits About Chemical Hair Straighteners' Link to Cancer — StockSnap / pixabay

By Daniel Okafor

Reuters reported Monday that four women who alleged their use of chemical hair relaxers led to uterine and ovarian cancer diagnoses reached a confidential settlement after a trial began in Chicago last week. The settlement amounts remain undisclosed, according to Reuters. Reuters noted that a settlement does not mean a defendant admitted wrongdoing or liability.

Reuters identified the four women receiving settlements as MaryAnne Lindsey, Surenthia Jenkins, Miranda Lofton and Sandra Simpson. Legal representation for the women told Allure that all defendants settled. Reuters described L’Oréal USA as the U.S. subsidiary of the world’s largest beauty conglomerate. L’Oréal USA is among the defendants.

A spokesperson for L’Oréal USA wrote to Allure: “Our highest priority is the health and wellbeing of all our consumers. Our products are subject to a rigorous scientific evaluation of their safety by experts who also ensure that we strictly follow all regulations in every market in which we operate.”

The spokesperson added: “We stand by the safety of SoftSheen-Carson's products.” Allure identified SoftSheen-Carson's as the specific L’Oréal brand named in the complaints.

Danielle Ward Mason, the group’s attorney, said in a statement to Allure: “From our first client meetings to the morning of opening statements, MaryAnne, Surenthia, Miranda and Sandra stood firm, and I’m proud they have reached a resolution through the settlement of their cases.”

She continued: “These women trusted the Defendants’ assurances that these hair relaxer products were safe, and they have paid a heavy price for that trust.”

Mason also said: “From the very beginning, our goal has been to make sure women harmed by these products are heard and compensated, and that the companies that put them on the market are held accountable.”

“Our team came to Cook County ready to put these cases in front of a jury, and I’m incredibly proud of how hard everyone fought and of the result we achieved for these clients. I hope this resolution gives these four women a sense of justice after everything they have been through,” Mason said.

Mason added: “This is an important step, but our work is far from over. Every woman harmed by these products deserves justice, and the next generation deserves real protections and honest warnings about their safety. I will keep fighting until every woman harmed by these products gets the justice she deserves.”

Allure cited recent research on the health implications of chemical hair straighteners, including heightened risks of ovarian and uterine cancers. It said the products are most often created for and marketed to Black women. The report linked that research to a growing series of lawsuits against multiple manufacturers in recent years.

Reuters reported that more than 12,700 cases have been consolidated, or grouped, before a Chicago judge. Allure also reported that, in September, Arizona’s attorney general sued L’Oréal for consumer fraud, alleging the conglomerate downplayed product health risks.

L’Oréal told Allure at the time that it “believe[s] the allegations made in this lawsuit have neither legal nor scientific merit.”

What does this settlement change for the more than 12,700 cases?

It resolves the claims of four plaintiffs without deciding liability. Every defendant in the case settled, and the four women received undisclosed compensation. The agreement does not resolve the consolidated litigation or establish new product-safety rules.

Allure described the deal as the first settlement of its kind found in its reporting. It said the agreement’s meaning for the remaining cases and the future of chemical hair straighteners remains to be seen.

Mason’s next stated objective is compensation, real protections and honest warnings. Allure said the settlement’s broader market impact remains unresolved.

via reuters.com (Original)

Filed under

Share this article:

More from Daniel Okafor

Daniel Okafor

Show full bio

News editor covering money, funding and market shifts around skincare, haircare, makeup, fragrance, nails at Eurasian Beauty Journal.

137 articles

Also on the counter

« Previous article